The Historical Sociology of Rural-Urban Development by James Scott: Against Simplifications

This article is a critical analysis of the historical and sociological works of the American political anthropologist J. S. Scott (1936-2024). His works were largely related to the study of the contradictions of social development between the city and the village. This topic is presented especially deeply and comprehensively in Scott's monographs of his late intellectual period: 'Seeing Like a State' (1998), 'The Art of Being Ungovernable' (2006), and 'Against the Grain' (2016). In these works, Scott analyzed—practically in retrospective order—several key rural-urban contradictions and paradoxes of social development from the era of high modernism of the 19th-20th centuries to the era of the emergence of the first city-states in the 6th millennium BC. Scott based his analysis on extensive regional comparative studies and interdisciplinary research at the intersection of history, sociology, anthropology, cultural studies, ecology, and political science. The problem of the formation, development, and expansion of state power in matters of regulating relations between city and countryside are core themes of these works. On the other hand—in matters of state-controlled relations between city and countryside—Scott highlights the influence of a third force, a third party: the so-called stateless, unsettled barbarism and anarchy that wedges itself into the regulation of rural-urban contradictions.

1. Arendt H. (2011) On Revolution. M.: Izdatelstvo “Europa”. — in Russ.

2. “A Short Course in the History of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks)". The text and its history. (2014) In 2 parts. Part 1. History of the text of “A Short Course in the History of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks)”. 1931-1956. Compiled by M. V. Zelenov, D. Brandenberger. Moscow: ROSSPEN. — in Russ.

3. Lenin V. I. (2021) What is to be done? Urgent issues of our movement. — М.: URSS.

4. Moor B. (2016) Social origins of dictatorship and democracy: the role of the landowner and the peasant in the creation of the modern world. — M.: Publishing house of the Higher school of economics. — in Russ.

5. Nikulin A. M. (2012) From Neolithic Domestication to Imperial Settlement: J. Scott's

6. Nikulin A. M. (2022) James Scott and Alexander Chayanov: From the Peasantry through revolutions, to the states, and anarchies. Russian Sociological Review, 21(3): 202-228. — in Russ. https://doi.org/10.17323/1728-192x-2022-3-202-228

7. Platonov A. (1987) Descendants of the Sun. Stories and Novels. M.: Pravda. — in Russ.

8. Scott J. S. (2005) By the Good Intentions of the State. M.: University Book. — in Russ.

9. Scott J. C. (2017) The Art of not Being Governed: An Anarchic History of Upland Southeast Asia. M.: New Publishing House. — in Russ.

10. Scott J. C. (2019) Anarchy No, But Yes! M.: Radical Theory and Practice. — in Russ.

11. Scott J. C. (2020) Against the Grain. The Deep History of the Earliest States. M.: Delo Publishing House. — in Russ.

12. Tyunen I. G. (1926) Isolated state. M.: Ekon. life. — in Russ.

13. Shanin T. (2012) On the ethnographic sociology of James Scott. Sociology of power, (4-5): 9-16. — in Russ.

14. Shanin T. (1999) Expolar Economies: Political Economy of Social Margins. Informal Economy. Russia and the World. M.: Logos: 545-554. — in Russ.

15. Boserup E. (1965) The Conditions of Agricultural Growth: The Economics of Agrarian Change under Population Pressure. Chicago: Aldine; London: Allen & Unwin.

16. Clastres P. (1987) Society against the State. New York: Zone Books.

17. Harvey D. (1989) The condition of postmodernity: An inquiry into the origins of social change. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

18. Pournelle J. (2003) Marshland of Cities: Deltaic Landscapes and the Evolution of Early Mesopotamian Civilization. University of California at San Diego.

19. Scott J. C. (1993) Domination and the art of resistance: hidden transcripts. New Haven: Yale University Press.

20. Thompson E. P. (1963) The Making of the English Working Class. London, UK: Victor Gollancz Ltd. p. 848.

21. Thompson E. P. (1971) The moral economy of the English crowd in the eighteenth century. Past & Present, 50(1): 76-136.

22. Thompson E. P. (1975) Whigs and Hunters: The Origin of the Black Act. London: Allen Lane, 1975.