Political Agency of Children in the New Sociology of Childhood and Beyond

Abstract

The article is a review of theoretical discussions about children’s agency in the new sociology of childhood, on the one hand, and a review of empirical studies of children’s political agency, on the other. These two fields often discuss the same problem, but look at it from different perspectives. Childhood theorists debate what children’s agency is and whether the search for it should be critical. Some of them continue to postulate the need to consider children as social actors, while others criticize this position for its ahistorical nature, normative charge, and simplified understanding of agency and subjectivity. Empirical researchers of children’s political participation are not too concerned with the conceptualization of the very concept of agency, but the materials of their research allow us to understand how children themselves in different situations discursively construct their agency — as more progressive than that of an adult; as no different from an adult; as interconnected with an adult; or even as inferior to an adult. Children do not deprive themselves of agency out of nowhere; such deprivation can be explained by both class factors and factors associated with the characteristics of socialization. Thus, studies of children’s political participation strengthen the grounds for criticizing the “naive” attitude to seek children’s political agency a priori, but at the same time they call into question the possibility of one, “correct” definition of children’s (political) agency. The review of discussions and findings in both areas ends with a formulation of problems and questions that childhood researchers, including Russian ones, have yet to resolve.