Eric Voegelin — Critic of “Gnostic Socialism” of Karl Marx

   The article is devoted to the criticism of the revolutionary ideas of Karl Marx by the great political thinker of the 20^th century, Eric Voegelin (1901-1985). The article shows that Voegelin’s criticism of the Marxist doctrine consists of several successive stages. In his works of the late 1930s, he develops the idea of Marxism and communism, which grew up on its ideological basis, as one of the main “political religions” of the XX century. In the 1940s, when Voegelin was living in exile in the United States, he continued to criticize the Marxism of Marx, but on a new theoretical basis, at the center of which was the concept of “gnosticism” as the essence of Western modernity. Since the 1950^s, Voegelin’s interest in the Marxism of Marx gradually faded away, and the Marxist doctrine itself is mostly mentioned as an example of one of the variants of “gnosticism” of the 20th-century politics. As a theoretical horizon of Voegelin’s criticism of the Marxian revolutionary idea, a brief reconstruction of the main propositions of his political theory as an experimental and critical science of the correct order of the soul and society is presented. Voegelin’s thesis that the rise of “gnosticism” is the essence of Western modernity is also analyzed in detail, since it serves as the central point of his interpretation of modern intellectual history. The article shows that the spiritual basis on which the development of the Marxian revolutionary idea took place was the revolt of the young Marx against God and his desire to eliminate the higher, transcendent and creative divine principle from the picture of the world of modern man. Voegelin's final conclusion, proposed by him in the framework of criticism of the Marxian revolutionary idea, is that the political success of Marxism in the XX century is one of the most significant symptoms of the spiritual decline of Western civilization.

1. Bulgakov S. N. (1990 [1906]) Karl Marx as a religious type. S. N. Bulgakov. The Philosophy of Economy, Moscow: Science: 310-342. — in Russ.

2. Marx K. (1956a [1839‒1841]) The difference between the natural philosophy of Democritus and the natural philosophy of Epicurus. K. Marx, F. Engels. From early works, Moscow: State Publishing House of Political Literature: 17-98. — in Russ.

3. Marx K. (1956b [1844]) Economic and philosophical manuscripts. K. Marx, F. Engels. From early works, Moscow: State Publishing House of Political Literature: 517-642. — in Russ.

4. Marx K., Engels F. (1985 [1845/1846]) German ideology. K. Marx, F. Engels. Selected works, in 9 volumes. Vol. 2. Moscow: Politizdat: 5-508. — in Russ.

5. Germino D. (1964) Eric Voegelin’s Contribution to Contemporary Political Theory. The Review of Politics, 6 (3): 378-402.

6. Herz D. (2004) The concept of “political religions” in the thought of Eric Voegelin. H. Maier (Ed.) Totalitarianism and Political Religions. Vol. I. Concepts for the comparison of dictatorships, L.: Routledge: 149-165.

7. Seitschek H. O. (2003) Eric Voegelin’s Concept of “Gnosis”. H. Maier (Ed.) Totalitarianism and Political Religions. Vol. III. Concepts for the comparison of dictatorships: theory and history of interpretation, L.: Routledge: 214-221.

8. Voegelin E. (1950) The Formation of Marxian Revolutionary Idea. The Review of Politics, 12 (3): 275-302.

9. Voegelin E. (1958) Wissenschaft, Politik und Gnosis, München: Kösel.

10. Voegelin E. (1975) From Enlightenment to Revolution, Durham (N. C.): Duke University Press.

11. Voegelin E. (1993 [1938]) Die politischen Religionen, München: Fink.

12. Voegelin E. (1994 [1941]) Das Volk Gottes. Sektenbewegung und der Geist der Moderne, München: Fink.

13. Voegelin E. (1999 [1960]) Religionsersatz. Die gnostischen Massenbewegungen unserer Zeit. E. Voegelin. Der Gottesmord. Zur Genese und Gestalt der modernen politischen Gnosis, München: Fink: 105-128.

14. Voegelin E. (2000a) Gnostic Politics (1952). E. Voegelin. The Collected Works of Eric Voegelin. Vol. 10. Published Essays 1940‒1952, Columbia: University of Missouri Press: 223-240.

15. Voegelin E. (2000b). The Collected Works of Eric Voegelin. Vol. 17. The Ecumenic Age, Columbia: University of Missouri Press.