Apophatic and Cataphatic Ways of Soviet Political Theology

   The discourse of political theology developed by Schmitt makes it possible to identify a secular religion in Marxism. Marxism is aimed at achieving an “earthly paradise”. In the Soviet project, based on the “dictatorship of the worldview” (Berdyaev), its own political theology is being formed, including apophatic and cataphatic elements. The apophatic content is connected with the totalization of the denial of the ideals, laws, and order of the old world. Hobbes sees in the state a Leviathan — a powerful mortal god, whom God is able to catch and tame at any moment. Taking the side of the Behemoth in the fight against Leviathan, the revolutionary forces are focused on the negative ontological connection that arises during the collapse of the state between Leviathan and God, whose place in the revolutionary consciousness is occupied by the laws of history. The apophatic theology of the Soviet project is built in the logic of increased attention to revolutionary upheavals, punishing Leviathan for unworthy behavior. As a result, the Soviet revolutionary project is deconstructing and destructive in nature. Revolutionary forces, personifying righteous anger, radicalize the fight against the discovered “social evil”, entering an area of the escalation of violence. A necessary condition for building a “new world” is the consistent destruction of the old one “to the foundations”. However, at the moment of gaining power, the revolutionary forces abandon the apophatic and enter the cataphatic path. The main dogma for social construction is the position of communism as the inevitable future of human history. Blind faith in the inevitability of communism is ill-suited to see what God, or the laws of history, allows Leviathan to do. The struggle against the dehumanizing essence of capitalism gradually contributes to the construction of an equally dehumanizing society (Berdyaev) — an ideological, bureaucratic, planned-distributive total state. Rampant communal forces (Zinoviev) create new hierarchies and a new social division. Ideology takes frozen “hypernormal” forms that do not correspond to reality. In the end, the mismatch of social and ideological projects during the “performative shift” (Yurchak) entails the collapse of the USSR, illustrating the new revelation of the divine pacification of Leviathan.

1. Autonomova N. S. (2011) The Philosophical Language of Jacques Derrida, M.: Russian Political Encyclopedia (ROSSPEN). — in Russ.

2. Agamben G. (2021) Creation and Anarchy. The work in the era of capitalist religion, M.: Gilea. — in Russ.

3. Agamben G. (2019) Kingdom and Glory. To the Theological Genealogy of Economics and Management, M.: Gaidar Institute; Saint Petersburg: Faculty of Liberal Arts and Sciences of St. Petersburg State University. — in Russ.

4. Bakunin M. (1919) Selected works. Vol. Two. The Knuto-German Empire and the Social Revolution, M.: The Voice of Labor Publishing House. — in Russ.

5. Bakunin M. (1920) Selected works. Vol. IV. The politics of the International. Letters to a Frenchman. Paris Commune, Saint Petersburg–M.: Publishing house “Voice of labor”. — in Russ.

6. Bakunin M. (1921) Selected works. T. V. “Alliance” and the International. International and Mazzini, St. Petersburg, M.: The Voice of Labor Publishing House. — in Russ.

7. Bateson G. (2000) Ecology of the Mind, M.: Smysl. — in Russ.

8. Berdyaev N. (1955) The Origins and Meaning of Russian Communism, Paris: YMCA-PRESS. — in Russ.

9. Graeber D. (2016) Utopia of Rules: about Technology, Stupidity and the secret charm of bureaucracy, Moscow: Ad Marginem Press. — in Russ.

10. Dostoevsky F. M. (2008) Collected works: Brothers Karamazov: Novel. Ch. 1, 2, M.: The World of books, Literature. — in Russ.

11. Durkheim E. (2018) Elementary forms of religious life: the totemic system in Australia, M.: Publishing House “Delo” RANHiGS. — in Russ.

12. Zinoviev A. A. (1994) Communism as Reality, M.: Tsentrpoligraf. — in Russ.

13. Ilyin I. A. (1996) Collected works: In 10 Vols. Vol. 1, Moscow: Russian Book. — in Russ.

14. Konacheva S. A. (2022) “God without sovereignty” and the “sacred anarchy” of the Kingdom: “weak” theology as a theopolitical project. Sociological Review. Vol. 21, No. 2. 214-229. — in Russ.

15. Kordonsky S. G. (2007) Resource state: collection of articles, M.: REGNUM. — in Russ.

16. Lenin V. I. (1973) Complete works : in 55 vols. 23. March-September 1913, M.: State Publishing House of Political Literature. — in Russ.

17. Lossky V. N. (2012) An essay on the Mystical Theology of the Eastern Church. Dogmatic theology. Trans. from the French Mon. Magdalena (V. A. Reschikova), Sergiev Posad: STSL. — in Russ.

18. Merridale K. (2019) Stone night. Death and Memory in Russia of the twentieth century, M.: AST Publishing House. — in Russ.

19. Moscovici S. (1998) The Century of Crowds. Historical treatise on the psychology of the masses, M.: Center of Psychology and Psychotherapy. — in Russ.

20. Novgorodtsev P. I. (1991) On the Social ideal, M.: Press. — in Russ.

21. Ranciere J. (2006) On the edge of the political, M.: Praxis. — in Russ.

22. Solovey V. D. (2016) Revolution! Fundamentals of the revolutionary struggle in the modern era, M.: Eksmo. — in Russ.

23. Vögelin E. (2021). New Science of Politics, Saint Petersburg: Vladimir Dahl. — in Russ.

24. Filippov A. (2015) Hannah Arendt and Carl Schmitt: Two concepts of the political. The modern meaning of Hannah Arendt’s ideas. Materials of the international conference. Kaliningrad: Publishing House of the Baltic Federal University named after I. Kant. pp. 52-65. — in Russ.

25. Chestnov I. L. (2012) Postclassical theory of Law. Monograph, Saint Petersburg: Publishing House “Alef-Press”. — in Russ.

26. Schmitt K. (2000) Political Theology, M.: CANON-press-Ts. — in Russ.

27. Schmitt K. (2005) Dictatorship. From the origins of the modern idea of sovereignty to the Proletarian class struggle, Saint Petersburg: Nauka. — in Russ.

28. Schmitt K. (2006) Leviathan in the Doctrine of the State by Thomas Hobbes, Saint Petersburg: Vladimir Dahl. — in Russ.

29. Schmitt K. (2007) Theory of the partisan, M.: Praxis. — in Russ.

30. Schmitt K. (2008) Nomos of the Earth in the law of peoples jus publicum europaeum, Saint Petersburg: Vladimir Dahl. — in Russ.

31. Schmitt K. (2016) The Concept of the political, Saint Petersburg: Nauka. — in Russ.

32. Junger E. (2000) Worker. Domination and Gestalt; Total mobilization; About Pain, Saint Petersburg: Nauka. — in Russ.

33. Yurchak A. (2014) It was forever until it was over. The Last Soviet Generation, M.: New Literary Review. — in Russ.

34. Yurchak A. (2020) And his body lives. What secrets Lenin’s mausoleum hides (https://lenta.ru/articles/2020/04/22/lenin150/). — in Russ.

35. Yarkeev A. V. (2022) On the question of the possibility of political theology: Karl Schmitt polemizes with Eric Peterson. Sociological Review. Vol. 21, No. 2. 189-213. — in Russ.

36. Agamben G. (2015) Stasis. Civil War as a Political Paradigm (Homo Sacer II, 2), Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.

37. Caputo J. D. (2006) The Weakness of God: A Theology of the Event, Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

38. Caputo J. D. (2019) Cross and Cosmos: A Theology of Difficult Glory, Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

39. Gentile E. (2001) Politics as Religion, Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press.