Preview

Sociology of Power

Advanced search

The Spectre of the Soviet Man

EDN: NLKIPW

Abstract

The article restores the theoretical logic behind Yuri Levada and his team’s 
research project, “Soviet Man”. Based on the project’s publications, the article reconstructs both the “early” model, which included a set of attitudes 
toward the “antinomies” of the Soviet system, as well as the later model 
which emphasized a set of adaptive characteristics (“adapted”, “two-faced”, 
etc.). The empirical and theoretical foundations that prompted the authors 
of the project to abandon the original hypothesis about the “disappearing type” of the Soviet man are clarified. There is a connection between 
the dynamics of the “Soviet Man” project and the early theoretical works 
of Yuri Levada in the 1970s and 1980s; specifically, there is a shift in his 
interests from structural analysis to action problems. The theoretical prerequisites of the critical texts of the Levada of the post-Soviet period (the 
concepts of “social change”, “degenerate case”) are clarified. The role of 
the general methodological guidelines of the Levada group is emphasized: 
“transposing” the concepts of Western sociology in describing the Soviet / 
Russian case; elucidating the historical context in which the terms arose; 
attempting a comparison with the “generalized West”, the obligatory linking of research tasks to the “big problems” of their society Possibilities of 
updating (“reverse transposing”) the theoretical developments of Levada 
within the framework of the academic community that does not share 
the basic methodological principles of the project are discussed. As possible topics for academic discussion, a comparison of the conceptions of 
modernization in the USSR —introduced by Levada and the late Parsons 
in the System of Modern Societies—is proposed, as well as the possibilities of the Levada’s concept for explaining and predicting social changes 
across generations.

About the Authors

Алексей Титков
МВШСЭН
Russian Federation


Alexey S. Titkov
MSSES
Russian Federation

Associate Professor



References

1. Adorno T., Frenkel-Brunswik E., Levinson D., Sanford D. (2001 [1950]) The Authoritarian Personality, M.: Akademiya Issledovaniy Kul’tury.—in Russ.

2. Almond G., Verba S. (2014 [1963]) The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy

3. in Five Nations, M.: Mysl.—in Russ.

4. Aron R. (1993 [1967]) Main Currents in Sociological Thought, M.: Progress,

5. Univers.—in Russ.

6. Bikbov A., Gavrilenko S. (2002) Russian Sociology: Autonomy in Question.

7. Logos, (5-6): 1-25.—in Russ.

8. Bikbov A., Gavrilenko S. (2003) Russian Sociology: Autonomy in Question (Part 2).

9. Logos, (2): 51-85.—in Russ.

10. Vakhshtayn V. (2009) Beyond Post-Soviet Sociology: Paradoxes and Tautologies.

11. Ways of Russia: Contemporary Intellectual Space: Schools, Turns, Generations, Vol. XVI,

12. Vorozheikina T. (2008) Values Orientation or Methodical Limits. Russian Public

13. Opinion Herald, (4): 62-69.—in Russ.

14. Gabowitsch M. (2008) To The Discussion on Theoretical Legacy of Yuri Levada.

15. Russian Public Opinion Herald, (4): 50-61.—in Russ.

16. Gudkov L. (2006) On the Situation of Social Sciences in Russia. New Literature

17. Observer, (1): 314-339—in Russ.

18. Gudkov L. (2007) “Soviet Man” in Yuri Levada’s Sociology. Social Sciences and

19. Contemporary World, (6): 16-30.—in Russ.

20. Gudkov L. (2008a) Limited Sanity Society. Russian Public Opinion Herald, (1):

21. -32.—in Russ.

22. Gudkov L. (2008b) Issues of Yuri Levada’s Sociology. Universe of Russia, (3):

23. -36.—in Russ.

24. Gudkov L. (2009) Conditions for “Soviet Man” Reproduction. Russian Public

25. Opinion Herald, (2): 8-37.—in Russ.

26. Gudkov L. (2010) Does Theoretical Sociology Have Ground in Russia. Sociological

27. Journal, (1): 104-125.—in Russ.

28. Gudkov L. (2011) Abortive Modernization, M.: ROSSPEN.—in Russ.

29. Gudkov L. (2011) Person in Non-Moral Area: Toward Sociology of Morality in

30. Post-Totalitarian Society. Russian Public Opinion Herald, (3-4): 118-179.—in Russ.

31. Dimke D. (2012) Classics without Classics: Social and Cultural Origins of Soviet

32. Sociology Style. Sociological Studies (Socis), (6): 97-106.—in Russ.

33. Dubin B. (2007) Tradition, Culture and Game in Sociology of Yuri Levada. Social Sciences and Contemporary World, (6): 31-38.—in Russ.

34. Dubin B. (2010) Late Soviet Society in Sociological Working of Yuri Levada in 1970s. Social Sciences and Contemporary World, (5): 101-110.—in Russ.

35. Simmel G. (1996 [1890]) Social Differentiation: Sociological and Psychological Studies. Simmel G. Selected Works. Vol. 2. View of Life, M.: Yurist: 301-465.—in Russ.

36. Inkeles A. (1972 [1968]) Personality and Social Structure. American Sociology: Perspectives, Problems, Methods, M., Progress: 31-53.—in Russ.

37. Levada Y. (1993 [1979]) On Reproductive System Model Specification (Conceptual Framework Issues). Levada Y. Articles on Sociology, M.: 50-60.—in Russ.

38. Levada Y. (1993 [1983]) Issues of Economic Anthropology by Karl Marx. Levada Y. Articles on Sociology, M.: 71-87.—in Russ.

39. Levada Y. (1993 [1984]) Game Structures in Systems of Social Action. Articles on Sociology, M.: 99-119.—in Russ.

40. Levada Y. (1993 [1989]) Dynamics of Social Breakdown: The Possibilities of Analysis. Articles on Sociology, M.: 159-176.—in Russ.

41. Levada Y. (2000) Homo Post-Soveticus. Social Sciences and Contemporary World, (6): 5-24.—in Russ.

42. Levada Y. (2000) “Soviet Man”: Public Lecture at Polit.ru. Polit.ru. April 15.—In Russ.

43. Levada Y. (2005 [2000]) Generations of XX Century: The Possibilities for Study. Levada Y., Shanin T. Fathers and Sons: Contemporary Russia Generations Study, M.: New Literary Observer: 39-60.—in Russ.

44. Levada Y. (2008) “To Act Differently Would be Unnatural, I Thought”. Sociological Journal, (1): 155-174.—in Russ.

45. Levada Y. (2011 [1969]) Lectures on Sociology, Moscow: Publisher E.V. Karpov.—in Russ.

46. Levada Y. (2011 [1969]) Soviet Man Five Years After: 1989–1994. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 57-73.—in Russ.

47. Levada Y. (2011 [1996]) “Soviet Man” Phenomenon Revisited: Issues of Analysis Methodology. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 74-90.—in Russ.

48. Levada Y. (2011 [1996]) Soviet Man Ten Years After: 1989–1999. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 111-145.—in Russ.

49. Levada Y. (2011 [1996]) Adapted Man. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 146-173.—in Russ.

50. Levada Y. (2011 [2000]) Sly Man: Doublethink Russian Style. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 197:223.—in Russ.

51. Levada Y. (2011 [2000]) Limited Man: Levels and Frames of Aspirations. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 224-246.—in Russ.

52. Levada Y. (2011 [2001]) Framework for Human. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 275-300.—in Russ.

53. Levada Y. (2011 [2003]) “Soviet Man” in the Era of Changes. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 366-387.—in Russ.

54. Levada Y. (2011 [2003]) “Soviet Man” and His Self-Identification Frame. Selected Works: The Problem of Human Being, M.: Publisher E.V. Karpov: 408-433.—in Russ.

55. Levada Y. (2011 [2003]) “The Vanishing Kind?”. The Time of Changes: Subject Matter and Researcher’s Position, M.: New Literary Observer: 481-498.—in Russ.

56. Levada Y. (2016 [2000]) Diagnosis: Aggressive Mobilization with Asthenic Syndrome. The Time of Changes: Subject Matter and Researcher’s Position, M.: New Literary Observer: 597-601.—in Russ.

57. Levada Y. (ed.), Golov A., Grazhdankin A., Gudkov L., Dubin B., Zorkaya N., Levinson A., Sedov L. (1993) Soviet Simple Man: An Attempt of Sociological Portrait at the Turn of 90s, M.: Mirovoj Okean.—in Russ.

58. Levada Y., Dolgy V., Levinson A. (1993 [1974]) Urbanization as Socio-Cultural Process. Articles on Sociology, M.: 24-38.—in Russ.

59. Levada Y., Dolgy V., Levinson A. (1993 [1976]) Toward Problem of Social Time-Space Change in Urbanization Process. Articles on Sociology, Moscow: 39-49.—in Russ.

60. Levada Y., Notkina T. (1989) The Measure of All Things. A. Vishnevsky (ed.). In Human Dimension, M.: Progress: 11-24.—in Russ.

61. Luhmann N. (1991 [1987]) Tautology and Paradox in the Self-Descriptions of Modern Society. Socio-Logos: Sociology. Anthropology. Metaphysics. Issue 1. Society and

62. Realms of Sense, M.: Progress: 194-215.—in Russ

63. Editorial Preface (2008) Russian Public Opinion Herald, (4): 50.—in Russ.

64. Parsons T. (1998 [1971]) The System of Modern Societies, M.: Aspekt-Press.—in Russ.

65. Parsons T. (2002a [1937]) The Structure of Social Action. On Structure of Social Action, M.: Academic Project: 43-328.—in Russ.

66. Parsons T. (2002b [1966]) On Social Systems, M.: Academic Project: 779-828.—in Russ.

67. Radaev V. (2000) What Chance to Create Russian National Theory in Social Sciences? Pro et Contra, (3): 202-214.—in Russ.

68. Radaev V. (2018) A Farewell to Soviet Simple Man. Social Sciences and Contemporary World, (3): 51-65.—in Russ.

69. Radaev V. (2019) Millenials: How Russian Society Changes, M.: HSE Publishing House.—in Russ.

70. Semenova V. (1998) Sociology of Youth. V. Yadov (ed.) Sociology in Russia, M.: Institute of Sociology Publishing House: 130-147.—in Russ.

71. Sogomonov A. (1994) Review of “Soviet Simple Man: An Attempt of Sociological Portrait at the Turn of 90s”. Sociological Journal, (1): 182-185.—in Russ.

72. Sogomonov A. (1998) Sociology of Culture: Theoretical Aspect. Sociology in Russia, M.: Institute of Sociology Publishing House: 335-345.—in Russ.

73. Sokolov M. (2009) Russian Sociology After 1991: Intellectual and Institutional Dynamics of “Poor Science”. Laboratorium, (1): 20-57.—in Russ.

74. Sokolov M. (2012) On Academic (De)civilizing Process. Sociological Studies (Socis), (3): 21-30.—in Russ.

75. Sokolov M., Titaev K. (2013) Provincial and Indigenous Scholarship. Forum for Anthropology and Culture, (19): 239-275.—in Russ.

76. Filippov A. (2013) Soviet Sociology as Policy Science. New Literary Observer, (5): 48-63.—in Russ.

77. Kharkhordin O. Reveal and Dissimulate: A Genealogy of Russian Personality, St. Petersburg: EUSP Press; M.: Letniy Sad.—in Russ.

78. “Cynical, Two-Faced, Apathetic: Why “Soviet Man” Keeps Living Among Russians and Forces Them to Endure and Suffer (2019). Lenta.ru, May 24.—in Russ.

79. Yurchak A. (2014) Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More: the Last Soviet Generation, M.: Neprikosnovennij Zapas.—in Russ.

80. Inkeles A., Bauer R. (1959) The Soviet Citizen, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

81. Scott J. (1985) Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance, New Heaven:

82. Yale University Press.

83. Parsons Т., Bales R., Shils E. (1953) Working Papers in the Theory of Action, New York:

84. The Free Press.


Review

For citations:


 , Titkov A.S. The Spectre of the Soviet Man. Sociology of Power. 2019;31(4):53-94. (In Russ.) EDN: NLKIPW

Views: 1


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2074-0492 (Print)
ISSN 2413-144X (Online)