Preview

Sociology of Power

Advanced search

From Science to Utopia: Marcuse and Critical Utopianism

https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2024-4-64-102

Abstract

The article examines the concept of utopia in its post-Marxist context. Since the 1970s—against the backdrop of the failures of May 68, the self-exposures of the USSR, and the decline of the workers’ movement, as well as in accordance with the immanent history of the logic of the history of philosophy itself—the concept of utopia has been running through new areas of meaning and is extremely dialectical in two modes: temporal and ontological. The first transforms utopia from never-being into “past”, the second provides two inversions, considering it as 1) a dystopia, the other of utopia, which is declared to be the hidden truth of utopia; and — when it is fundamentally possible according to its own concept — 2) as impossible, in connection with which utopia and its concept return to the discourse as a kind of empty place around which modern pessimism circles, correctly believing that the future is unimaginable. The time of ends, from the end of the grand narratives of disappointed radicals (Lyotard) to the end of politics (see Rancière’s analysis), is, however, picked up by Marcuse, who suggests considering utopia as ahistorical. The author introduces this strange ahistorical or even anti-historicalism as historical, relying on the conceptualized phenomenon of the desynchronization of the “base” (the development of productive forces to the degree necessary for social revolution) and the “superstructure”, which runs into a limit, since it cannot represent the restrained base, which has broken out of the formational “scientific” logic. When Marcuse writes that a utopia in the strict sense can now be called a project that violates the laws of nature, he means the “impossible” into which utopia turns after the catastrophes of the 20th century, betraying the truth of its concept contained in the simple possibility of another world. More than 50 years after “The End of Utopia” and almost 30 years after the ontological turn in philosophy, we can say that utopia is still unimaginable — in the strict sense is what violates the laws of logic. This thesis opens up the possibilities of a new dialectic and its alliance with transcendentalism, which the author considers as a critique of plastic reason in the spirit of Malabou, constructing time and time again the assumptions-concepts that it needs and which are “practically necessary” according to Kant.

About the Author

L. A. Agamalova
M. V. Lomonosov Moscow State University
Russian Federation

Lolita A. Agamalova — PhD student at the Department of Ontology and Theory of Knowledge, Faculty of Philosophy

Moscow



References

1. Agamben G. (2018) The Time that Remains: A Commentary on the Letter to the Romans. М.: New Literary Review. — in Russ.

2. Agamben G. (2012) Homo Sacer. Remnants of Auschwitz: The Witness and the Archive, М.: Europa Press. — in Russ.

3. Adorno T., Bloch E. (2011) Something is missing. On the contradictions of utopian longing. Moscow Art Magazine, (84, part 2): 40-52. — in Russ.

4. Adorno T. (2023) Minima moralia. Reflections on a Damage Life, M.: Ad Marginem. — in Russ.

5. Aristotle (1976) Metaphysics. Works in 4 vol. Vol. 1, M.: Thought. — in Russ.

6. Badiou А. (2012) Manifesto for Philosophy, St. Petersburg: Machina. — in Russ.

7. Baumgarten A. G. (2012) Preface. Prolegomena to metaphysics. Part 1. Ontology: prolegomena. Chap. 1. ΕΙΝΑΙ: Problems of Philosophy and Theology, (vol. 1, 1/2): 141- 156. — in Russ.

8. Benjamin W. (2004) Left melancholy. Benjamin W. Masks of Time. Essays on Culture and Literature. St. Petersburg: Symposium: 377-384. — in Russ.

9. Benjamin W. (2012) Critique of Violence. Benjamin W. The doctrine of semblance. Media Aesthetic Works. M.: RSUH: 65-100. EDN: QXCRAB — in Russ.

10. Benjamin W. (2012). Theses of Philosophy of History. Benjamin W. The doctrine of semblance. Media Aesthetic Works. M.: RSUH: 237-254. EDN: QXCRAB — in Russ.

11. Brassier R. (2024) Laruelle and the Reality of Abstraction. Another One, (1): 161- 197. — in Russ.

12. Wallerstein I. (2006) Utopisticks, or Historical Choices of the Twenty-First Century. Prognosis, (5): 8-57. — in Russ.

13. Vasiliev N. (1989) Imaginary Logic. Selected works, M.: Science: 94-123. — in Russ.

14. Wittgenstein L. (2017) Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, M.: Canon+. — in Russ.

15. Wittig M. (2002) The Straight Mind and other essays, Moscow: Idea Press. — in Russ.

16. Hegel G. W. F. (2021) Science of Logic. The science of logic. Objective logic. The doctrine of being, M.: Academic Project. — in Russ.

17. Hegel G. W. F. (2010) The Phenomenology of Spirit, M.: Academic Project. — in Russ.

18. Husserl E. (2010) Cartesian Meditations, M.: Academic Project. EDN: QWYHCN — in Russ.

19. Deleuze J. (1998) Difference and Repetition, St. Petersburg: Petropolis. EDN: TCNXL — in Russ.

20. Derrida J. (2006) Specters of Marx, М.: Logos-altera, EcceHomo. EDN: QWNODL — in Russ.

21. Derrida J. (2012) Différance. Derrida J. Margins of Philosophy. M.: Academic Project: 1-29. EDN: QXEVXR — in Russ.

22. Descartes R. (1938) Geometry. With an appendix of selected works, M.: Thought. — in Russ.

23. Jameson F. (2011) Politics of Utopia. Art Journal, (84): 10-26. — in Russ.

24. Ilyenkov E. (1980) Leninist Dialectics and the Metaphysics of Positivism, M.: Gospolitizdat. — in Russ.

25. Kant I. (2008) Critique of Pure Reason, M.: Academic Project. — in Russ.

26. Kant I. (1994) Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason. Kant I. Works in 8 vol. Т. 6. М.: CHORO. — in Russ.

27. Kant I. (2006) Critique of Pure Reason. Works in German and Russian. Vol. 2, part 2. M.: Science: A261. — in Russ.

28. Kant I. (1994) Critique of Pure Reason. Works in 8 vol. Т. 3. M.: CHORO: V317. — in Russ.

29. Malabou C. (2012) Another possibility. Art Journal, (85): 60-72. — in Russ.

30. Malabou C. (2018) Can we relinquish the Transcendental? Philosophical Journal, (1): 99-110. EDN: YXBGXA. https://doi.org/10.21146/2072-0726-2018-11-1-99-110 — in Russ.

31. Malabou C. (2019) What Should We Do with Our Brain? М.: V-A-C Press. — in Russ.

32. Mannheim K. (1991) Ideology and Utopia. Utopia and utopian thinking, M.: Progress: 113-170. — in Russ.

33. Marx K. (1937) The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte, M.: Gospolitizdat. — in Russ.

34. Marx K., Engels F. (1955) Works, 2nd ed. Vol. 1. M.: Gospolitizdat: 379. — in Russ.

35. Marcuse H. (2011) Note on dialectics. Marcuse H. The Critical Theory of Society. M.: AST: 139-150. EDN: QXAWZN — in Russ.

36. Marcuse H. (2004) The End of Utopia. Logos, (6): 18-23. EDN: XHTCCV — in Russ.

37. Meillassoux Q. (2024) The Immanence of the World Beyond. Another One, 2: 125-163. — in Russ.

38. Meillassoux Q. (2015) After Finitude: An Essay on the Necessity of Contingency. М.: Cabinet scientist. — in Russ.

39. More T. (1978) Utopia, М.: Science. — in Russ.

40. Parmenides (1989) On Nature. Fragments of Early Greek Philosophers, М.: Science: 274-298. — in Russ.

41. Plato. Parmenides (1993) Plato. Collected Works in 4 vols. Vol. 2. M.: Thought: 346-412. — in Russ.

42. Plato. Sophist (1993) Plato. Collected Works in 4 vols. Vol. 2. Moscow: Though: 275-346. — in Russ.

43. Popper K. (2004) The Logic of Scientific Research, M.: Republic. EDN: QWGQOP — in Russ.

44. Popper K. (1993) The Poverty of Historicism, M.: Progress Publishing Group. — in Russ.

45. Priest G. (2022) Beyond the Limits of Thought, M.: Canon+. — in Russ.

46. Rancière J. (2006) On the Shores of Politics, M.: Praxis. EDN: QOFQSF — in Russ.

47. Rancière J. (2013) Disagreement, St. Petersburg: Machina. — in Russ.

48. Sartre J.-P. (2000) Being and Nothingness: An Essay in Phenomenological Ontology, M.: Republic. — in Russ.

49. Safronov V. (2022) The position of the dead. Revisionist History of «Russian Cosmism», M.: V-A-C Press. — in Russ.

50. Fedorov N. (2015) Museum, its meaning and purpose. Groys B. Russian cosmism. Anthology. M.: Ad Marginem. — in Russ.

51. Frege G. (1997) Selected Works, M.: House of Intellectual Book. — in Russ.

52. Foucault M. (1994) Words and Things, M.: Progress. — in Russ

53. Heidegger M. (2017) Hegel. Negativity. Dealing with Hegel, M.: Vladimir Dal. — in Russ.

54. Heidegger M. (2007) What is Metaphysics? M.: Academic Project. — EDN: QWRAIV in Russ.

55. Choran E. (1997) The Mechanics of Utopia. Foreign Literature, (4). — in Russ.

56. Szacki E. (1990). Utopiya i tradiciya, M.: Progress. — in Russ.

57. Schmitt K. (2000) Political Theology, М.: KANON-Press-C. — in Russ.

58. Engels F. (1937) The Development of Socialism From Utopia to Science, M.: Young Guard. — in Russ.

59. Hume D. (1996) An Inquiry into Human Cognition. Hume D. Works in 2 vols. Т. 2. M.: Thought: 3-145. — in Russ.

60. Malabou C. (2004) The Future of Gegel. Plasticity, Temporality and Dialectic, New York: Routledge.


Review

For citations:


Agamalova L.A. From Science to Utopia: Marcuse and Critical Utopianism. Sociology of Power. 2024;36(4):64-102. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2024-4-64-102

Views: 548


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2074-0492 (Print)
ISSN 2413-144X (Online)