Police/Militia in (Post-)Soviet Popular Culture (Towards a Historical Iconography of Power)
https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2024-3-136-163
Abstract
The idea of the police as a "good order” from the Polizeiwissenschaft of absolutism was developed in the biopolitical model of caring for the population of the Modern era, engaged in ensuring safety and well-being. Being a product of mass society, the modern state has focused on influencing public opinion. In the XIX-XX centuries, there was a counter-movement of police supervision and art which gave rise to 'police aesthetics'. Cinematography was an effective means of forming a desirable image of the Soviet militia in the post-war period of normalization of public life. By contributing to the Soviet myth of developed socialism, militia cinema contributed to a screento-life transfer of a new norm of trust between representatives of power and citizens. This constructivist cinema involved the viewer in the cinematic reality by likening them to the main character, a militiaman who acts as a moral guide. In addition to forming the image of the 'familial militia', intellectual militia cinema — with its focus on professionalism — is actively developing. The most popular version of the latter is militia cinema that thematizes the moral rightness of militia officers fighting crime in the name of Soviet citizens. Involvement in the cinematic reality through assimilation, novelty, memory, and imagination included the romanticization of the historical events of the revolution. Militia cinema was inverted during the years of the perestroika. It exploited the effect of novelty associated with the viewer's immersion in emerging market relations. The viewer's interest was focused on the wrong, criminal, side of public life. Crime is romanticized, the militia is stigmatized. From constructing the myth of cooperation between the government and the population, militia cinema moves on to deconstructing the myth, achieving an effect of denigration. The fashion for American cinema brings elements of action, thriller, horror. The viewer is no longer included in the imperious project of transforming reality; they are attracted by the illusion, the spectacle. The latest police cinema, overcoming total deconstructionism, is busy reconstructing the spirit of Soviet militia cinema in modern settings. Oscillating between the intention to generate positive images of the police and the demonstration of the "truth of life”, modern police cinema contains the natal shoots of a new cinema in which the image of the police is important for the normalization of public life.
About the Author
D. V. PopovRussian Federation
Dmitry V Popov — Doctor of Philosophical Science, Associate Professor, Head of Department of Philosophy and Political Science
Omsk
References
1. Agamben G. (2015) Means without Purpose: Policy Notes, Moscow: Gileja. — in Russ.
2. Agamben G. (2019) Kingdom and Glory. To the Theological Genealogy of Economics and Management, M.: Gaidar Institute; Saint Petersburg: Faculty of Liberal Arts and Sciences of St. Petersburg State University. — in Russ.
3. Arendt H. (2017) The Human Condition. Moscow: Аd Marginem Press. — in Russ.
4. Baiburin A. (2017) The Soviet Passport: History — structure — practices, Saint Petersburg: Publishing House of the European University in St. Petersburg. — in Russ.
5. Bernays E. (2021) Propaganda, Saint Petersburg: Peter. — in Russ.
6. Vaculescu K. (2021) Police aesthetics. Literature, Cinema and the Secret Police in the Soviet Era, Saint Petersburg: BiblioRossika; Boston: Academic Studies Press. — in Russ.
7. Visual anthropology: modes of visibility under socialism (2009) Moscow: OOO "Variant", TSPGI. — in Russ.
8. Graeber D. (2016) Utopia of Rules: about Technology, Stupidity and the secret charm of bureaucracy, Moscow: Ad Marginem Press. — in Russ.
9. Darnton R. (2010) Poetry and the Police. The network of communications in Paris of the XVIII century, Moscow: New Literary Review. — in Russ.
10. Ishchenko N. (2023) Porfiry Petrovich as Socrates in the plot of "Crimes and Punishments" Dostoevsky and World Culture. Philological Journal, 2(22): 45-56. — in Russ. https://doi.org/10.22455/2619-0311-2023-2-45-56
11. Kildyushov O. V. (2013) Police as science and politics: on the birth of a modern order from philosophy and police practice. Russian Sociological Review, 12(3): 9-40. — in Russ.
12. Lippman W. (2023) Public opinion. Moscow: AST Publishing House. — in Russ.
13. oscovici S. (1998) The Century of Crowds. Historical treatise on the psychology of the masses, M.: Center of Psychology and Psychotherapy. — in Russ.
14. Nikolin I. V. (2007) The ontological specificity of cinema reality: abstract... PhD in Philosophy Sciences, Omsk: Publishing House of OmSPU. — in Russ.
15. Filippov A. (2015) Hannah Arendt and Carl Schmitt: Two concepts of the political. The modern meaning of Hannah Arendt's ideas. Materials of the international conference. Kaliningrad: Publishing House of the Baltic Federal University named after Kant: 52-65. — in Russ.
16. Foucault M. (2011) Security, territory, population. A course of lectures delivered at the College de France in the 1977-1978 academic year, Saint Petersburg: Nauka. — in Russ.
17. Yarkeev A. V. (2018) Ontological foundations of evil in modern society:philosophical and hermeneutic aspect, Yekaterinburg, Izhevsk: IFiP UrO RAS. — in Russ.
Review
For citations:
Popov D.V. Police/Militia in (Post-)Soviet Popular Culture (Towards a Historical Iconography of Power). Sociology of Power. 2024;36(3):136-163. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2024-3-136-163