Politicization of Theology and Theologization of Politics: Dialogue Between Jan Assmann and Carl Schmitt

The article examines the problems of the genesis of political theology as a phenomenon and the specificity of political theology as a method based on the concepts of Jan Assmann and Carl Schmitt. Analysing the development of political religion in Jewish political theology as a phenomenon and political theology as a sociological method provides new insights into the tasks of political theology as a syncretic political, theological, anthropological and sociological method. This method not only explores the changing relationship between power and religious order, but also identifies its actual origins. The examination of this genesis is traversed through the key concepts of “theologization of politics” (Assmann) and “politicization of theology” (Schmitt). An analysis of Schmitt's method of political theology itself, with reference to Assmann's analysis of political theology, leads to the conclusion that Schmitt theologizes political theology by presenting it as a single mechanism and stripping it of the content that could legitimise secular power. The political theology that emerged in Judaism, conditioned by the gap between theory and practice, makes possible the act of legitimation circulating between divine law and its fulfilment. Schmitt, however, shifts the focus from the internal circulation of legitimation to the principle itself. This principle is enunciated by the sociology of legal concepts, a method that not only establishes the substantive identity of the metaphysical picture of the world and the legal system, but to some extent strips this identity of the intrinsic distinction of being-in-itself, which metaphysics/theology tries to think through, and being-for-itself, which political praxis arranges according to the metaphysical premise but does not coincide with it completely. The article therefore concludes that the notion of political theology in Assmann's theory is the most constructive and historically validated, whilst also having great potential for deconstructing both historical politicaltheological models and the political-theological method itself.

1. Agamben G. (2019) Kingdom and Glory. Toward a theological genealogy of economics and management. Moscow; St. Petersburg: Gaidar Institute Publishing House, Faculty of Liberal Arts and Sciences of St. Petersburg State University. — in Russ.

2. Assman Y. (1999) Egypt: theology and piety of early civilization, Moscow: Priscels. — in Russ.

3. Assmann J. (2022) Political theology between Egypt and Israel, St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal. — in Russ.

4. ДGentile E. (2021) Between democracy and totalitarianism, St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal. — in Russ. EDN: VOCNUQ

5. Zizek S., Milbank J. (2020) The Monstrousness of Christ, Moscow: Ripol-Classic. — in Russ.

6. Kildushov O. (2013) Between law and politics. Schmitt C. State: Law and Politics, Moscow: Publishing House «Territoriya budushchego»: 7-26. — in Russ.

7. Löwith K. (2012) Political decisionism. Logos, (5): 115-142. — in Russ.

8. Löwith K. (2021) Meaning in History. The Theological Implications of the Philosophy of History, St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal. — in Russ.

9. Meier H. (2012) Carl Schmitt, Leo Strauss and «The Concept of the Political», Moscow: Skimen. — in Russ.

10. Filippov A. (2012) Political theology and sovereign dictatorship: Carl Schmitt on Joseph de Maistre. Relevance of Joseph de Maistre: Materials of the Russian-French conference, Moscow: RSUH: 227-238. — in Russ.

11. Voegelin E. (2021) New science of politics. Introduction, St. Petersburg: Vladimir Dal. — in Russ.

12. Filippov A. (2015a) On the background of «Political Theology». Gefter. URL: https://gefter.ru/archive/14981. Date of publication: 04/27/2015. — in Russ.

13. Filippov A. (2015b) The political romanticism of Carl Schmitt. C. Schmitt. Political romanticism, Moscow: Praxis: 317-380. — in Russ.

14. Friedman R. (2011) How the Bible was created, Moscow: Eksmo. — in Russ.

15. Shishkov A. (2022) Political theology. Great Russian Encyclopedia: scientific and educational portal. URL: https://bigenc.ru/c/politicheskaia-teologiia-962537/?v=5645036. Publication date: 06/01/2022. Update date: 11/28/2022m. — in Russ.

16. Schmitt C. (2005) Dictatorship. From the origins of the modern concept of sovereignty to the proletarian class struggle, St. Petersburg: Nauka. — in Russ.

17. Schmitt C. (2000) Political Theology. C. Schmitt. Political theology. Collection, Moscow: KANON-press-C: 7-98. — in Russ.

18. Schmitt C. (2010) The Führer Protects the Law. C. Schmitt. State and political form, Moscow: Higher School of Economics Publishing House: 263-270. — in Russ.

19. Schmitt C. (2013a) Legality and legitimacy. C. Schmitt. State: Law and Politics, Moscow: Publishing House «Territoriya budushchego»: 307-355. — in Russ.

20. Schmitt C. (2013b) On three types of juristic thought. C. Schmitt. State: Law and Politics, Moscow: Publishing House «Territoriya budushchego»: 221-305. — in Russ.

21. Schmitt C. (2015) Political romanticism, M.: Praxis. — in Russ.

22. Schmitt C. (2016a) The concept of the political. C. Schmitt. The concept of the political, St. Petersburg: Nauka: 60-92. — in Russ.

23. Schmitt C. (2016b) Roman Catholicism and political form. C. Schmitt. The concept of the political, St. Petersburg: Nauka: 60-92. — in Russ.

24. Schmitt C., Filippov, A. (2013) Legality and legitimacy (afterword to the 1958 edition). Sociological Review, 12(3): 76-92. — in Russ.

25. Yarkeev A. (2022a) Toward the Question of the Possibility of Political Theology: C. Schmitt Argues with E. Peterson. Sociological Review, 2: 189-213. — in Russ.

26. Yarkeev A. (2022b) Political myth in the teachings of Carl Schmitt. Discourse-Pi, 19 (2): 10-23. — in Russ.

27. Assmann J. (2005) Political Theology: Religion as a Legitimizing Fiction in Antique and Early Modern Critique. Giesen B., Šuber D. (Hrsgg.). Religion and Politics. Cultural Perspectives, Leiden, London: 193-203.

28. Assmann J. (2008) Of God and Gods: Egypt, Israel, and the Rise of Monotheism, Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

29. Assmann J. (1998) Moses the Egyptian, Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press.

30. Assmann J. (2011) Cultural memory and early civilization: writing, remembrance, and political imagination, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511996306

31. Assmann J. (2018) Invention of religion: faith and covenant in the book of exodus, Princeton, Oxford: Princeton University Press.

32. Friedman B. M. (2022) Religion And The Rise Of Capitalism, New York: Vintage. https://doi.org/10.1057/s11369-023-00315-5

33. Grabbe L. (2017) Ancient Israel: What Do We Know and How Do We Know It?, London: Bloomsbury Publishing.

34. Kervegan J.-F. (2011) Que faire de Carl Schmitt, Paris: Gallimard.

35. Marder M. (2010) Groundless Existence: The Political Ontology of Carl Schmitt, London, New York: Continuum.

36. Mccarraher E. (2019) The enchantments of Mammon: how capitalism became the religion of modernity, Cambridge: The Belknap Press Of Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42520-020-00313-3

37. Meier H. (2011) The lesson of Carl Schmitt: four chapters on the distinction between political theology and political philosophy, Chicago: The University Of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226189352.001.0001

38. Meyers C. (2005) Exodus, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

39. Milbank J. (2006) Theology and social theory: beyond secular reason, Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

40. Nelson E. (2019) The Theology of Liberalism, Cambridge: The Beklknap Press Of Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.32725/cetv.2023.012

41. Novak M. (1991) The spirit of democratic capitalism, New York: Madison Books.

42. Raschke C. (2020) Neoliberalism and Political Theology, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

43. Robbins J. W. (2011) Radical Democracy and Political Theology, New York: Columbia University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1755048312000521

44. Russell B. D. (2007) The song of the sea: the date of composition and influence of Exodus, 15: 1-21, New York: Peter Lang.

45. Salter M. (2012) Carl Schmitt. Law as Politics, Ideology and Strategic Myth, New York: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203125762

46. Schmitt C. (2008) Political Theology II, Malden, Cambridge: Polity Press.

47. Steinmetz-Jenkins D. (2011) Jan Assmann and the Theologization of the Political. Political Theology, 12(4): 511-530. https://doi.org/10.1558/poth.v12i4.511

48. Vatter M. (2020) Divine Democracy: Political Theology After Carl Schmitt, New York: Oxford University Press.

49. Wellhausen J. (1885) Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, Edinburgh.