Violence and the Sacred as the Topos of 20st–21st Century French Thought
https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2022-4-8-28
Abstract
The article considers the conceptual pair of violence and the sacred as a commonplace (“topos”) of French scientific, philosophical, and religious thought of the 20th–21th centuries and explains why this pair was so relevant and attracted many dissimilar thinkers. Six authors are taken as the main examples: G. Bataille, R. Caillois, R. Girard, E. Levinas, M. Eliade, and J. Kristeva. For analytic purposes, the author identifies three “common factors” that unite them. Firstly, the influence of the French sociological school (Durkheim, Hubert and Moss, Dumezil, Hertz etc.). Among other things, these scholars studied the religious meaning of blood, violent ascetics and sacrifice, conceptualizing violence as a pledge of social cohesion (Durkheim) or as a factor of transition from the profane to the sacred world (Hubert and Moss). Secondly, the ideas of these six thinkers were inspired by real violence, which they tried to comprehend via the concept of the sacred. In particular, their reflection was influenced by the cultural and personal experience of world wars. Third, this conceptual pair is value-charged and used to create a new religion or interpret the existing ones in heterodox way. As starting point for this creative process, Catholic or Orthodox Christianity, Christian atheism, and Judaism are taken. The author concludes that even if this topos is forgotten today, it undoubtedly remains significant for the history of sociology and philosophy, as well as for cultural history.
Supporting agencies: The article was written on the basis of the RANEPA state assignment research programme.
About the Author
A. Zygmont
RANEPA
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Aleksei I. Zygmont — Cand Sci. (Philosophy), Senior Research Fellow, Research Laboratory for Complex Historical Research, School for Advanced Studies in the Humanities, Institute for Social Sciences
Moscow
References
1. Zenkin S. (2014) TheNon-Divine Sacred: Theory and Literary Practice, Moscow: Russian State University for the Humanities. — in Russ.
2. Zygmont A., DyukovD. (2017) G. Bataille’s and R. Girard’s Philosophy of Violence and the Sacred in Comparative Perspective. Researches in Religious Studies, 1 (15): 29–72. — in Russ.
3. Zygmont A. (2018) Holy Negativity: Violence and the Sacred in Georges Bataille’s Philosophy, Moscow: New Literary Observer. — in Russ.
4. Ivanov V. (2009) The Origins and Transformations of the Ballad of the Master Manole’s Fabula. Selected Works in Semiotics and Cultural History. Т. 5. Mythology and Folklore, Moscow: Znak: 307–320. — in Russ.
5. Konacheva S. (2019) God after God: Ways of Post-Metaphysical Thinking, Moscow: Russian State University for the Humanities. — in Russ.
6. Laignel-Lavastine A. (2002) Cioran, Eliade, Ionesco. L’oubli du fascisme: trois intellectuels roumains dans la tourmente du siècle, Presses universitaires de France. — in Russ.
7. Pylaev M. (2018) The Category of the Sacred in the Phenomenology of Religion, Theology and Philosophy in the 20th Century, Moscow: Russian State University for the Humanities. — in Russ.
8. «Contre-Attaque». Union de lutte desintellectuelsrévolutionnaires (1970). Bataille G. Œuvres complètes. T. 1, Gallimard: 379–383.
9. Arppe T. (2009) Sacred Violence: Girard, Bataille and the Vicissitudes of Human Desire. Distinktion: Journal of Social Theory, 10 (2): 31–58.
10. Bataille G. (1976a) La théorie de la religion. Œuvres complètes. T. 7, Gallimard: 181– 280.
11. Bataille G. (1976b) La Limite de l’utile. Œuvres complètes. T. 7, Gallimard: 181–280.
12. Bataille G. (1987) L’Ėrotisme. Œuvres complètes. T. 10, Gallimard: 7–269.
13. Bataille G. (1988a) La guerre et la philosophie du sacré. Œuvres complètes. T. 12, Gallimard: 47–57.
14. Bataille G. (1988b) Le pur bonheur. Œuvres complètes. T. 12, Gallimard: 478–490.
15. Baudrillard J. (1976) L’échange symbolique et la mort, Gallimard.
16. Baudrillard J. (2007) L’esprit du terrorisme. Le Monde.
17. Caillois R. (1950) L’homme et le sacré, Gallimard.
18. Caillois R. (2012) Bellone, ou la pente de la guerre, Flammarion.
19. Clément C., Kristeva J. (1998) Le féminin et le sacré, Stock.
20. Direk Z. (2015) Bataille and Kristeva on Religion. J. Biles, Kent L. Brintnall (eds.) Negative Ecstasies. Georges Bataille and the Study of Religion, Fordham University Press: 182–201.
21. Dubuisson D. (2014) Twentieth Centuries Mythologies, Routledge.
22. Dumézil G. (1948) Mitra-Varuna, Gallimard.
23. Durkheim É. (2007) Les Formes élémentaires de la vie religieuse, CNRS Éditions.
24. Eliade M. (1937) De ce cred în biruinţa Mişcării Legionare. Buna Vestire, 244: 1–2.
25. Eliade M. (1965) Le sacré et le profane, Gallimard.
26. Galletti M. (éd.) L’Apprenti sorcier: du Cercle communiste démocratique à Acéphale. Textes, lettres et documents (1931–1939) (1999), Éd. de la Différence.
27. Girard R. (1972) La violence et le sacré, Grasset & Fasquelle.
28. Girard R. (1978) Des choses cachées depuis la fondation du monde, Grasset & Fasquelle.
29. Girard R. (2001) La théorie mimétique et la théologie. Celui par qui le scandale arrive: entretiens avec Maria Stella Barberi, Fayard.
30. Girard R. (2007) Achever Clausewitz, Carnets Nord.
31. Goldhammer J. (2005) The Headless Republic: Sacrificial Violence in Modern French Thought, Cornell University Press.
32. Grottanelli C. (2005) Fruitful Death: Mircea Eliade and Ernst Jünger on Human Sacrifice, 1937–1945. Numen, 52 (1): 116–145.
33. Haven C. (2018) Evolution of Desire: A Life of René Girard, Michigan State University Press.
34. Hollier D. (éd.) (1995) Le Collège de Sociologie. 1937–1939, Gallimard.
35. Hubert H., Mauss M. (1899) Essai sur la nature et la fonction du sacrifice. L’Année sociologique, 2: 29–138.
36. Kirwan M. (2005) Discovering Girard, Cowley Publications.
37. Kirwan M. (2009) Girard and Theology, T&T Clark.
38. Kristeva J. (1977) Hérétique de l’amour. Tel Quel, 74: 30–49.
39. Kristeva J. (1980) Pouvoirs de l’horreur. Essai sur l’abjection, Seuil.
40. Kristeva J. (2010) Hatred and Forgiveness, Columbia University Press.
41. Kristeva J. (2013) Visionscapitales: Artset rituels dela décapitation, Éd. de la Martinière.
42. Levinas E. (1963) Difficile liberté. Essais sur le judaïsme, Ėditions Albin Michel.
43. Levinas E. (1990) Nine Talmudic Readings, Indiana University Press.
44. Palaver W. (2013) René Girard’s Mimetic Theory, Michigan State University Press.
45. Reineke M. (1997) Sacrificed Lives: Kristeva on Women and Violence, Indiana University Press.
46. René Girard and Raymund Schwager. Correspondence 1974–1991 (2018) S. Cowdell, C. Fleming, M. Moonsbrugger (eds.) Bloomsbury Academic.
47. Richman M. (2005) The Sacred Group: A Durkheimian Perspective on the Collège de sociologie. Bataille: Writing the Sacred, Routledge: 58–76.
48. Rusu M. (2016) The Sacralization of Martyric Death in Romanian Legionary Movement: Self-sacrificial Patriotism, Vicarious Atonement, and Thanatic Nationalism. Politics, Religion & Ideology, 17 (2–3): 1–25.
49. Săndulescu V. (2007) Sacralised Politics in Action: The February 1937 Burial of the Romanian Legionary LeadersIon Moța and Vasile Marin. Totalitarian Movements and Political Religions, 8 (2): 259–269.
50. Schwager R. (1978) Brauchen wir einen Sündenbock? Gewalt und Erlösung in den biblischen Schriften, Munich: Kosel.
51. Strenski I. (2003) Theology and the First Theory of Sacrifice, Brill.
52. Surya M. (1987) Georges Bataille, la mort à l’œuvre, Gallimard.
53. Traylor A. (2014) Violence has its Reasons: Girard and Bataille. Contagion: Journal of Violence, Mimesis, and Culture, 21: 131–156.
Review
For citations:
Zygmont A. Violence and the Sacred as the Topos of 20st–21st Century French Thought. Sociology of Power. 2022;34(3-4):8-28. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2022-4-8-28
Views:
83
Email this article 