From Prefix Capitalism to Neoliberal Economism: Russia as a Laboratory in Capitalist Realism
https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2021-1-193-221
Abstract
This exploratory and review essay views Russia as a particular state-capital accommodation-assemblage characterized by neoliberal subjectivization of the population in a particularly stark manner. This argument is a departure from perspectives on Russia as a semi-periphery, instead proposing its thorough incorporation into the current moment of global capitalism. While 'state capitalism' has analytical purchase, 'authoritarian neoliberalism' is proposed as a more sharply focussed lens in examining Russia in the global context. This is important too in reorienting political economy to accommodate more grounded methodologies, including ethnography and other empirically subjective accounts. While beyond the scope of the essay, existing ethnographic accounts and empirical materials - particularly relating to Special Economic Zones in Russia are incorporated in the argument. In making its argument, the essay reviews the contribution of Foucauldian approaches to neoliberalism and neomarxian political economy. Then it reviews the varieties of capitalism approaches and their critics as well as the debates on state capitalism pertaining to Russia by Ilya Matveev, and as pertaining to state capitalism in general. Further the essay reviews recent work on Eastern Europe as providing examples of vanguard authoritarian neoliberal governance. Finally, this approach allows the essay to argue that Russia is not only a 'normal country', but that it anticipates contemporary developments towards more post-democratic capitalist futures, along with their counter-currents.
References
1. Alami I., Dixon A.D. (2020) The strange geographies of the ‘new’ state capitalism. Political Geography 82: 1-12.
2. Abramov R. (2019) Perevod. Ot Kommunizma k karnegizmu. Neprikosnovennyi zapas, 03(125): 52-168. van Apeldoorn B., de Graaff N., Overbeek H. (2012) The reconfiguration of the global state–capital nexus. Globalizations 9(4): 471–486.
3. Bedirhanoğlu P., Yalman, G.L. (2010) State, class and the discourse: Reflections on the neoliberal transformation in Turkey. A. Saad-Filho & G.L. Yalman (Eds.), Economic transitions to neoliberalism in middle-income countries. Abingdon: Routledge: 107–127.
4. Biebricher Th. (2018) The Political Theory of Neoliberalism. Stanford University Press.
5. Bindman E. (2017) Social Rights in Russia: From Imperfect Past to Uncertain Future. Routledge.
6. Bockman J., Gil Eyal (2002) Eastern Europe as a Laboratory for Economic Knowledge:
7. The Transnational Roots of Neoliberalism. The American Journal of Sociology, 108(2): 310-352.
8. Bruff I. (2014) The Rise of Authoritarian Neoliberalism. Rethinking Marxism, 26(1): 113-129.
9. Bruff I., Tansel C.B. (2019) “Authoritarian neoliberalism: trajectories of knowledge production and praxis”, Globalizations 16:3, 233-244.
10. Caffentzis G., Federici S. (2014) Commons against and beyond capitalism. Community Development Journal 49(1): 92-105.
11. Callinicos A. (2005) Epoch and Conjuncture in Marxist Political Economy, International Politics 42: 353-363.
12. Callinicos A. (2010) Bonfire of Illusions: The Twin Crises of the Liberal World. Cambridge: Polity.
13. Cetina K.K. (1999) Epistemic Cultures: How the Sciences Make Knowledge. Cambridge, Massachusetts; London, England: Harvard University Press.
14. Chernysh M. (2020) The structure of the Russian middle class. Social Distinctions in Contemporary Russia Waiting for the Middle-Class Society? Ed. by Jouko Nikula, Mikhail Chernysh. Routledge: 51-64.
15. Collier S.J. (2011) Post-soviet social: biopolitics, neoliberalism, social modernity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16. Collier S.J. (2012) Neoliberalism as big Leviathan, or … ? A response to Wacquant and Hilgers. Social Anthropology 20(2): 186–195.
17. Cook L.J. (2013) Postcommunist Welfare States: Reform Politics in Russia and Eastern Europe. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
18. Connolly R. (2018) Russia’s Response to Sanctions: How Western Economic Statecraft is Reshaping Political Economy in Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
19. Davies W. (2016) The Limits of Neoliberalism: Authority, Sovereignty and the Logic of Competition. Sage.
20. Dawisha K. (2014) Putin’s Kleptocracy: who owns Russia? New York: Simon and Schuster.
21. Deleuze G. (1990) Society of control. L’autre journal, 1: 177−182.
22. Derluguian G.M. (2005) Bourdieu’s Secret Admirer in the Caucasus. Chicago University Press.
23. Elias J., Rai S.M. (2018) Feminist everyday political economy: Space, time, and violence. Review of International Studies 45(2): 201–220.
24. Fabry A. (2019a) Neoliberalism, crisis and authoritarian–ethnicist reaction: The ascendancy of the Orbán regime. Competition & Change 23(2): 165–191.
25. Fabry A. (2019b) The Political Economy of Hungary: From State Capitalism to Authoritarian Neoliberalism. Palgrave Macmillian.
26. Fine B. (2010) Locating Financialisation. Historical Materialism, 18: 97-116.
27. Fisher M. (2008) Capitalist Realism: Is There No Alternative? Zero Books.
28. Fishwick A. (2014) Beyond and beneath the hierarchical market economy: Global production and working-class conflict in Argentina’s automobile industry. Capital & Class, 38(1): 115–127.
29. Friedman J. (2015) Global system crisis, class and its representations. J. Carrier & D. Kalb (Eds.), Anthropologies of Class: Power, Practice, and Inequality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 183-200.
30. Gago V. (2017) Neoliberalism from Below: Popular Pragmatics and Baroque Economies. Translated by Liz Mason-Deese, Durham and London: Duke University Press.
31. Geoghegan P. (2020) Cronyism and Clientelism. London Review of Books, 42(21): 5 November. https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v42/n21/peter-geoghegan/cronyism-andclientelism.
32. Geva D. (2021) Orbán’s Ordonationalism as Post-Neoliberal Hegemony. Theory, Culture & Society. Online first. DOI: 10.1177/0263276421999435.
33. Gimpelson V., Kapelyushnikov R., Lukyanova A. (2010) Employment Protection Legislation in Russia: Regional Enforcement and Labor Market Outcomes. Comparative Economic Studies 52: 611–636.
34. Golovchenko A.V. (2018) Post-Soviet Liberal Politicians: Political Expediency or Moral Imperative? Bulletin of the Moscow Region State University, 3: 3-20.
35. Gurkov I., Saidov Z. (2017) Current Strategic Actions of Russian Manufacturing Subsidiaries of Western Multinational Corporations. Journal of East-West Business, 23(2): 171-193.
36. Haggart B. (2018) The Government’s Role in Constructing the Data-Driven Economy. Centre for International Governance Innovation. 5 March 2018. https://www.cigionline.org/articles/governments-role-constructing-data-driven economy#:~:text=Data%20is%20what%20Polanyi%20would,conventions%20and%20human%2Dmade%20rules.&text=However%2C%20noted%20Polanyi%2C%20neither%20land,are%20actually%20created%20or%20produced
37. Hall P.A., Soskice D. (2001) An introduction to varieties of capitalism. Hall, P.A. and
38. Soskice, D., editors, Varieties of capitalism: the institutional foundations of comparative advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 1–68.
39. Hardt M., Negri A. (2004) Multitude: War and Democracy in the Age of Empire. New York: Penguin.
40. Harvey D. (1989) The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change. Wiley-Blackwell.
41. Harvey D. (2003) The New Imperialism (Oxford, Oxford University Press.
42. Hay C. (2004) The normalizing role of rationalist assumptions in the institutional embedding of neoliberalism, Economy and Society 33(4): 500-527.
43. Hemment J. (2009) Soviet-Style Neoliberalism? Nashi, Youth Voluntarism, and the Restructuring of Social Welfare in Russia. Problems of Post-Communism, 56(6): 36–50.
44. Hilgers M. (2012) The historicity of the neoliberal state. Social Anthropology, 20: 80–94. International Monetary Fund 2021. IMF Country Report No.21/36 Russian Federation. 26 February 2021. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/CR/Issues/2021/02/08/RussianFederation-2020-Article-IV-Consultation-Press-Release-Staff-Report-50068 Invest Kaluga ’Investitsionnyi portal’ https://investkaluga.com/
45. Jessop B. (2007) State Power: A Strategic-Relational Approach. Polity.
46. Kalb (2013) Financialization and the capitalist moment: Marx versus Weber in the anthropology of global systems. American Ethnologist 40(2): 258-266.
47. Katz R.S., Mair P. (1995) Changing Models of Party Organization and Party Democracy: the emergence of the cartel party. Party Politics 1(1): 5-31.
48. Khmelnitskaya M. (2017) The social budget policy process in Russia at a time of crisis.
49. Post-Communist Economies, 29(4): 457-475.
50. Kiossev A. (2018) Narrating life: Approaches to studying life narratives in the humanities and social sciences. Piron, 15, https://piron.culturecenter-su.org/alexanderkiossev-narration/1
51. Kordonsky S. (2016) Socio-Economic Foundations of the Russian Post-Soviet Regime. The Resource-Based Economy and Estate-Based Social Structure of Contemporary Russia. Stuttgart: Ibidem-Verlag.
52. Kourachanis N. (2020) Citizenship and Social Policy:From Post-War Development to Permanent Crisis. Palgrave.
53. Krylova A. (2000) The Tenacious Liberal Subject in Soviet Studies. Kritika 1(1): 119–46.
54. Kulmala M., Kainu M. J., Nikula J., Kivinen M. (2014) Paradoxes of Agency: Democracy and Welfare in Russia. Demokratizatsiya, 22(4): 523-552.
55. Larner W. (2000) Neo-liberalism: Policy, Ideology, Governmentality. Studies in Political Economy, 63: 5–25.
56. Lazzarato M. (2014) Signs and Machines: Capitalism and the Production of Subjectivity. Semiotext(e), Los Angeles CA.
57. Ledyaeva S., Karhunen P., Kosonen R., Whalley J. (2015) Offshore foreign direct investment, capital round-tripping, and corruption: Empirical analysis of Russian regions. Economic Geography, 91 (3): 305–341.
58. Lee Y. (1999) Labor Shock and the Diversity of Transnational Corporate Strategy in Export Processing Zones. Growth and Change, 30(3): 337–365.
59. Matveev I. (2019a) State, Capital, and the Transformation of the Neoliberal Policy Paradigm in Putin’s Russia. International Review of Modern Sociology 45(1): 27–48.
60. Matveev I. (2019b) Крупный бизнес в путинской России: старые и новые источники влияния на власть, Mir Rossii, 28(1): 54-74.
61. Merlingen M. (n.d.) A Neo-Gramscian Perspective on War in and Over Ukraine, unpublished paper. https://www.academia.edu/9677722/A_Neo_Gramscian_Perspective_on_War_in_and_Over_Ukraine?auto=download
62. Maidan M. (2014) Review of Maurizio Lazzarato Signs and Machines: Capitalism and the Production of Subjectivity Semiotext(e), Los Angeles CA, 2014. https://marxandphilosophy.org.uk/reviews/7947_signs-and-machines-review-by-michael-maidan/
63. Mirowski P. (2019) Hell Is Truth Seen Too Late. Boundary 2 46 (1): 1–53.
64. Moberg, L. (2014) The political economy of special economic zones. Journal of Institutional Economics 11(1): 167–190.
65. Molyarenko O. A. (2016) Shadow public administration. Monitoring of Public Opinion: Economic and Social Changes, 3: 120-133.
66. Morris J. (2012) Unruly Entrepreneurs: Russian Worker Responses to Insecure Formal Employment, Global Labour Journal 3.2.
67. Morris J. (2016) Everyday Post-Socialism: Working-Class Communities in the Russian Margins. Palgrave.
68. Morris J. (2019) The Informal Economy and Post-Socialism: Imbricated Perspectives on Labor, the State, and Social Embeddedness. Demokratizatsiya: The Journal of PostSoviet Democratization 27(1): 9-30.
69. Morris J., Hinz S. (2017) Free automotive unions, industrial work and precariousness in provincial Russia. Post-Communist Economies, 29(3): 282-96.
70. Orlova G., Morris J. (2021) Пандемия в (без)умном городе: цифровые протезы и аффордансы московской самоизоляции, in press, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
71. Ong A. (2006) Neoliberalism as Exception. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
72. Oorschot W. van, Gugushvili D. (2019) Retrenched, but Still Desired? Perceptions Regarding the Social Legitimacy of the Welfare State in Russia Compared with EU Countries. Europe-Asia Studies, 71(3): 345-364
73. Ovsyannikova A. (2016) Is neoliberalism applicable to Russia? A response to Ilya Matveev. Open Democracy, 20 May. https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/is-neoliberalism-applicable-to-russia-response-to-ilya-matveev/
74. Peck J. (2004) Geography and public policy: Constructions of neoliberalism. Progress in Human Geography, 28(3):392–405.
75. Peck J., Theodore N., Brenner N. (2009) Postneoliberalism and its Malcontents. Antipode, 41(1): 94–116.
76. Peck J., Tickell A. (2002) Neoliberalizing Space. Antipode, 34(3): 380-404.
77. Pieterse M. (2003) Beyond the Welfare State: Globalisation of Neo-Liberal Culture and the Constitutional Protection of Social and Economic Rights in South Africa. Stellenbosch Law Review, 14: 3–29.
78. Pokrovskii N.E., Bobylev S. (2003) Sovremennyi rossiiskii sever. Ot kletochnoi globalizatsiik ochagovoi sotsial’noi strukture . Moscow: GU-VShE.
79. Polese A., Kovács B., Jancsics D. (2017) Informality ‘in spite of’ or ‘beyond’ the state: some evidence from Hungary and Romania. European Societies, 20(2): 207-235.
80. Polese A., Prigarin A. (2013) On the persistence of bazaars in the newly capitalist world: reflections from Odessa. Anthropology of East Europe Review, 31(1): 110-136.
81. Poulantzas N. (1978) State, power, socialism. Trans. P. Camiller. London: New Left Books.
82. Rogers D. (2016) The Depths of Russia : Oil, Power, and Culture after Socialism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
83. Romanov P. (2008) Quality Evaluation in Social Services: Challenges for New Public Management in Russia. Peters, B. Guy (ed). Mixes, Matches, and Mistakes : New Public Management in Russia and the Former Soviet Republics. Budapest: Local Government and Public Service Reform Initiative, Open Society Institute.
84. Roy A. (2009) Why India Cannot Plan Its Cities: Informality, Insurgence and the Idiom of Urbanization. Planning Theory, 8(1): 83.
85. Rupprecht T. (2020) Global Varieties of Neoliberalism: Ideas on Free Markets and Strong States in Late Twentieth-Century Chile and Russia. Global Perspectives, 1 (1).
86. Fine B., Saad-Filho A. (2017) Thirteen Things You Need to Know About Neoliberalism. Critical Sociology, 43(4-5): 685-706.
87. Salmenniemi S., Adamson M. (2015) New Heroines of Labour: Domesticating Postfeminism and Neoliberal Capitalism in Russia. Sociology, 49(1): 88–105.
88. Sassen S. (2014) Expulsions: Brutality and Complexity in the Global Economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press/Belknap Book.
89. Shields S. (2019) The paradoxes of necessity: Fail forwards neoliberalism, social reproduction, recombinant populism and Poland’s 500Plus policy. Capital and Class, 43(4): 653-669.
90. Shleifer A., Triesman D. (2005) A Normal Country: Russia After Communism. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(1): 151-174.
91. Sosnovkikh S. (2017) Peculiarities in the Development of Special Economic Zones and Industrial Parks in Russia. European Journal of Geography, 8(4): 82-102.
92. Shevchuk A.V. (2020) From Factory to Platform: Autonomy and Control in the Digital Economy. Sociology of Power, 32(1): 30-54.
93. Sigman C. (2013) The “new public management” in Russia. The tribulations of a transposition. Government and public action, 2(3): 441-460.
94. Sitrin M.A. (2012) Everyday Revolutions: Horizontalism and Autonomy in Argentina. London: Zed Books.
95. Sparke M. (2013) Introducing Globalization: Ties, Tensions, and Uneven Integration. WileyBlackwell.
96. Standing G. (2011) The Precariat. The New Dangerous Class. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
97. Tansel C.B. (ed.) (2017) States of Discipline: Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Contested Reproduction of Capitalism Order. Rowman and Littlefield: Lanham Maryland.
98. Tyner J.A. (2013) Population geography I: Surplus populations. Progress in Human Geography 37(5): 701–711.
99. Wengle S., Rasell M. (2008) The monetisation of l’goty: Changing patterns of welfare politics and provision in Russia. Europe-Asia Studies, 60(5): 739-756.
100. Van der Pijl K. (2006) Global Rivalries From The Cold War To Iraq. London: Pluto Press.
101. Venkatesan S., Laidlaw J., Eriksen T.H., Martin K., Mair J. (2015) The concept of neoliberalism has become an obstacle to the anthropological understanding of the twenty-first century: 2012 debate of the Group for Debates in Anthropological Theory. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 21(4): 911.
102. Volkov V. (2002) Violent Entrepreneurs: The Use of Force in the Making of Russian Capitalism. Cornell University Press.
103. Yates M. (2011) The Human-As-Waste, the Labor Theory of Value and Disposability in Contemporary Capitalism. Antipode, 43(5): 1679–1695.
104. Zhao J., Tang J. (2018) Industrial structure change and economic growth: A ChinaRussia comparison. China Economic Review, 47: 219-233.
105. Zuboff S. (2015) Big Other: Surveillance Capitalism and the Prospects of an Information Civilization. Journal of Information Technology, 30: 75−89.
Review
For citations:
Morris J. From Prefix Capitalism to Neoliberal Economism: Russia as a Laboratory in Capitalist Realism. Sociology of Power. 2021;33(1):193-221. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-0492-2021-1-193-221
Views:
7
Email this article 