2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
‘Paper Body’: Bureaucratic and Legal Dimensions of the Newborn Patient’s Trajectory Within Neonatal Care
ru
Original Article|Sociology of Medicine and Health
AbstractFull textReferencesFilesAuthorsAltmetrics
This article explores the bureaucratic, legal and economic dimensions of the neonatal care. Drawing analytically on the neo-Weberian approach in the sociology of professions [Freidson 2001] and the anthropology of bureaucracy in medicine [Berg 1996; Berg & Bowker 1997], we propose to analyse the medical documents and the practices of its composition as both a constitutive element of medical practice and as organisational infrastructure that ensures the coordination of different professional groups and their interactions with patients. Specifically, we define this part of the work of doctors, nursing staff and health care managers in the context of neonatal resuscitation care as a process of creating and modifying a 'paper body' for their patients, i.e. all the document flow that accompanies the processes of treating and routing the patient. Empirically, the study relies on qualitative data collected within ‘the Birth of the Patient’ project: diaries of included observations of a neonatal intensive care physician, ethnographic observations by social researchers, focus groups with neonatal intensive care unit staff and interviews with medical professionals and healthcare managers. As a result of this data analysis, we find that the documentary history of the newborn patient is shaped by multiple negotiations between different medical professionals and representatives of different health care institutions. In some cases, the patient's 'paper body' turns out to be a major determinant of his or her future trajectory of (de)hospitalisation. We also find that the formation of such a documentary biography of a newborn patient does not directly correlate with his or her clinical condition, but reflects the complex system of distribution of material and non-material resources that constitute the newborn care service and in some cases goes beyond it.
Keywords: medical organizations, health professionals, newborn patient, neonatology, bureaucracy
ASJC: 3301
Article received: June 19, 2024
Article accepted: July 15, 2024
Baiburin A. K. (2017) Sovetskii pasport: istoriya-struktura-praktiki [Soviet passport: history — structure — practices]. St.Petersburg: Publishing house of the European University in St. Petersburg. — in Russ.
Klepikova, A., Altukhova, A., Mokhov, S. (2023) On the results of the study “Communication between doctors, volunteers and patients with ALS: problems and ways to solve them”, report at the VIII Annual Conference on ALS of the Foundation “Live Now”, (Moscow, May 18-19, 2023). — in Russ.
Minakov A., Novkunskaya A., Klepikova A. (2022) The Birth of the Patient: (De)medicalization of New-born Children in the Organizational Contexts of Neonatal Intensive Care. The Journal of Social Policy Studies, 20(2): 181-198. https://doi.org/10.17323/727-0634-2022-20-2-181-198
Mansurov V. A., Yurchenko, O. V. (2004) Perspectives of professionalization of Russian doctors in a reforming society. Russia Reforming, (4): 61-79. — in Russ.
Ugarova A. (2018) Strong drug: illigal prescription of drug painkillers and legal cases against physicians, ES Forum Bulletin, 2(58): 6-12. — in Russ.
Chernova J. V. (2013) Gender Analysis of Family Policy in Modern Russia: Features and Trends. PhD Thesis. Saratov: SSTU. — in Russ.
Shevchenko N. (2023) Bureaucratic Routes and Documentary Temporalities of a Conscript Questionnaire in a Human Rights Organization. Antropologicheskij forum, (59): 73-102. — in Russ. https://doi.org/10.31250/1815-8870-2023-19-59-73-102
Berg M. (1996) Practices of reading and writing: the constitutive role of the patient record in medical work. Sociology of health & illness, 18(4): 499-524.
Berg M., Bowker G. (1997) The multiple bodies of the medical record: Toward a sociology of an artifact. Sociological Quarterly, 38(3): 513-537.
Borozdina E., Novkunskaya A. (2022) Patient-centered care in Russian maternity hospitals: Introducing a new approach through professionals’ agency. Health, 26(2): 200-220.
Borozdina E. (2018) Introducing ‘natural’ childbirth in Russian hospitals. Midwives’ institutional work. Health, technologies, and politics in post-Soviet settings: Navigating uncertainties, 145-171.
Borozdina E. (2023) Evidence-based medicine and physicians’ institutional agency in Russian clinical settings. Critical Public Health (4): 1-12.
Field M. G. (1957) Doctor and patient in Soviet Russia. Harvard University Press.
Fitzpatrick S. (2005) Tear off the masks! Princeton University Press.
Freidson E. (2001) Professionalism, the third logic: On the practice of knowledge. University of Chicago press.
Goffman E. (1959) The moral career of the mental patient. Psychiatry, 22(2): 123-142.
Hull M. S. (2008). Ruled by Records: The Expropriation of Land and the Misappropriation of Lists in Islamabad. American Ethnologist, 35(4): 501–518. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1548-1425.2008.00095.x
Litvina D., Novkunskaya A., Temkina A. (2019) Multiple vulnerabilities in medical settings: invisible suffering of doctors. Societies, 10(1): 5. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc10010005
Rivkin-Fish M. (2010). Pronatalism, gender politics, and the renewal of family support in Russia: Toward a feminist anthropology of “maternity capital”. Slavic review, 69(3): 701-724. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0037677900012201
Rosenberg C. E. (2002) The tyranny of diagnosis: specific entities and individual experience. The Milbank Quarterly, 80(2): 237-260.
Strauss A., Schatzman L., Ehrlich D., Buche, R., Sabshin M. (1963) The hospital and its negotiated order (pp. 147-169). In The hospital in modern society.
© Article. Anastasia A. Novkunskaya, Artemiy A. Minakov, Anna A. Klepikova, 2024.